Friday 30 August 2013

Tunnel vision for Tigers

Last night's absorbing encounter with South Sydney may've ended in yet another defeat for Wests Tigers but the manner of defeat was arguably one for promise. The Tigers may've squandered an 18-0 lead in what was a golden chance to upset a title heavyweight. In truth though the 18 point head start was never going to be enough to win. For the record, Souths composed themselves and their strength, confidence and class shone through as they eventually sealed an admirable comeback victory when Nathan Merritt crossed with a little over 7 minutes remaining.

For the Tigers, their efforts were worth applauding. They showed confidence and troubled the Rabbitohs early on. James Tedesco was like a snake slivering through the bushes. Ever present and dangerous. Benji Marshall probed and poked at the Souths defensive line, to some success too, as he set up Tim Simona for the game's first try. For the second week running Marshall found some success in just getting in there and running the football. Braith Anasta, Robbie Farah and Liam Fulton directed the troops in the same direction and for a while Souths found themselves not only chasing the game but being pressured into mistakes and poor options.

A class side cannot be kept down for long though. Souths eventually gained control and with it the points came as they eventually finished the Tigers with little over 4 minutes left to play. The Tigers will be disappointed they couldn't find one more try. Had they, perhaps they go on and win the game. It wasn't through lack of trying but more so down to Souths ability to control the game and keep it tight defensively.

So what will the Tigers take out of the game? Forget the scores, forget the bunnies and just focus on the Tigers for a moment. Well first, they pushed Souths into a vulnerable position. They also wrestled with the bunnies for a good hour of the game before they lost their momentum for good. Perhaps though the biggest thing they'll take from the game is in just how far this side has come. Rewind back to early May, in round 10, Souths crushed the Tigers 54-10. The contest in that fixture was non existent. It was embarrassing! However on this late August night many of those same players got their return shot at the bunnies and proved how far they've come since that initial game.

James Tedesco was perhaps the best example. Perhaps the best player on the field last night after Issac Luke, Tedesco's game has come along way since that round 10 meeting. He was superb! The effectiveness of David Nofoaluma on the wing was hard to not be impressed by. Some of his work in getting the Tigers out of trouble was commendable  Curtis Sironen's effort in the back row against a monster pack only backed up his potential. These Tigers tried hard and matched their opponents in most departments. Only the class, confidence and experience of this Souths side went beyond the best the Tigers could offer. The Tigers though were admirable in defeat.

Last night wasn't so much about gaining revenge. Last night was a chance to prove to the league world that the Wests Tigers are better than the rap they're being given. It's safe to say that the dark days of early May are now well and truly behind us and that better days lie ahead. Yep, there's light at the end of this tunnel!


Tuesday 27 August 2013

Has Marshall got one more vintage Benji showing in him?

Amongst the many good performances from the Wests Tigers on Saturday afternoon at the SCG came a vastly improved performance from mercurial five eighth Benji Marshall. Marshall's form has been all too well documented this season with criticism raining down on him from virtually everywhere. So it was especially comforting to have Marshall return to something of his best against the Dragons.

It should be noted that very little of his play on Saturday structurally reflected that of his better games at five eighth though. A lot of his good work came from playing in the centres, where he made 16 runs for 133 metres. A fair few of those runs simply came from dummy half, but on occasion Marshall also caught the defence off guard by coming in field and searching for the ball. The best example of this was his play in the first half which put Braith Anasta over for a try. Here, Marshall came centre field off a quick play the ball and went right through the middle of an unsuspecting defence before linking up with Anasta who finished a great opportunistic try, Marshall utilized his vision very well against the Dragons, especially in the context above, but also won several penalties by observing an off side player and shooting straight for them to good effect.

The burning question now though is whether or not Marshall can replicate the same form on Friday night versus Souths. This game will be much tougher, obviously. For the Tigers to compete though, a more confident Marshall will go a long way. There's no doubt Benji's confidence will be up a little this week, even if he is back in the halves where he's struggled all season. Perhaps he'll be inspired by his 200th first grade game? An achievement that seemed no chance after a horrendous run of shoulder injuries in his early years??

There's no doubt Benji will reflect on it all at some point this week, and he has torn the Bunnies up on his own in the past. Has he got one more stellar game in him still? It may not even be good enough to beat a top team in Souths, though we can all dream and hope..........


 Benji Marshall v Dragons: 16 runs (133m), 1 try assist, 4 tackle breaks, 1 line break, 1 offload

Sunday 25 August 2013

A new dawn arises

Saturday afternoon's victory over the Dragons painted more than just the odd picture. Sure, the SCG is the grandest setting in a magnitude of sporting venues in Sydney. There was also the historic occasion of remembering the 1963 Grand Final between Wests and St George at the very same ground. But much like the SCG today, a lot has changed since that day. Like the SCG in many ways is almost unrecognizable from that day, Wests Tigers and St George-Illawarra represented a very much modern day formation - one for the joint venture era.

Further more though and perhaps my most significant observation, in a such a grand and historic setting, was seeing the likes of debutant Luke Brooks shine. For an 18 year old rookie, this debut was special. It had poise, maturity and class. He wasn't alone. Several other younger members of this Wests Tigers also shone. Tim Simona added another couple of tries to his breakout season and was as elusive as ever. James Tedesco was as assured as a good fullback should be. His dangerous support play in attack made this arguably his best performance of the season all round. Not to be forgotten too were Curtis Sironen who proved he has what it takes in the second row. Hooker Joel Luani is also cementing his spot as Robbie Farah's back up - a capable one at that.

However it can't be over looked. For as much as this was a team performance, the biggest talking point on Saturday's win, and rightly so, was the arrival of Luke Brooks. No. This is not the time to get all giddy about the fact that Wests Tigers may finally have a half back of the real deal on it's books. That will come in time - we hope. But the circumstances were undeniable. Brooks' debut came at the expense of Benji Marshall, who more or less spent the best part of the game in the centres. His role was almost more of a roving role. It was also a role he filled to great effect. It was unquestionably Marshall's best game of the year.

But as Marshall took a step back for the team, it was Brooks who stepped in. His distribution was very sound, he ran the football with great effect and his short kicking game was precise on more than a few occasions. His defence too was admirable. He forced loose balls on two carries, one that could've ended with a try conceded. That same tackle also lead to a long distance Tim Simona try on half time. It's also noted that he had his forwards running where he wanted them. It was a real encouraging performance!

Perhaps though the best picture that could've been painted on the day belonged to the moment where Brooks had put Curtis Sironen over for a try. There, embracing in the in goal to celebrate, basking in the afternoon sun were four of the Tigers generation next. Curtis Sironen, Luke Brooks, Tim Simona and James Tedesco. They stood there arm in arm, huddled in a circle almost as if there was real significance for themselves too. It could well end up a promotional tool for the Wests Tigers in 2014. It was a touching moment and the realization dawned that times are changing at Wests Tigers. The same path that had been trodden by our 2005 squad and was still being trodden in 2012 is now firmly shifting. A new era is beginning already

Wednesday 21 August 2013

Brooks to debut?

Reports this morning suggest Wests Tigers will hand a debut to highly regarded half back Luke Brooks. Any such situation would suggest that the club have gained an exemption from the NRL to include Brooks. Saturday's fixture with the Dragons at the SCG is officially a dead rubber with neither side capable of making the top 8 making it more favourable for the NRL to include Brooks.

At this stage the changes are anticipated as: Luke Brooks would come into the side at halfback, forcing Braith Anasta to slot to five-eighth with Benji Marshall set to move into the centres in place of Bodene Thompson.

At this stage these reports remain unconfirmed. So it's stressed that the above is not necessarily true. However in the likelihood that Brooks was to debut, this would appear the perfect game to choose, as mentioned above earlier. This morning @NothingButWT outlined the reasons as to why blooding Brooks this weekend was a good idea. I agree completely. Blooding Brooks this season makes a lot of sense. For one, he is in season now and the eyes of the league world are focused elsewhere. From the perspective of adding pressure to the kid, now is as good a time as any.

 Blooding Brooks next year seems a lost opportunity. Imagine having to sit through an entire pre season with the media's gaze staring you in the eye, anticipating the bright new spark, making his debut in round one. It's a perfect media beat up that will attract a lot of unnecessary hype. There's also the added advantage of giving him a taste this season so that the off season can be used to have him ready to go into a very specific pre season program aimed at improving what was assessed in his limited first grade time.

The bottom line is that there doesn't seem to be much point in holding him back any longer. There are only 3 games left this season, of which Brooks may be okay to play in two (v Dragons this weekend and R26 v Cowboys - depending on Cowboys finals chances). Andrew Johns, one of his biggest admirers feels Brooks is too good for the under 20's and appears ready for first grade now. He should know. Joey was one of the games greatest halfbacks. All that's left to ask then is whether or not it does happen this weekend. Time will tell, but I get the feeling the odds of him running out on Saturday are the highest yet.

"My Name is Brooks.....Luke Brooks."

Luke Brooks - He is not the next Joey Johns, He is not the next Benji Marshall, He is the next Luke Brooks.

Let me start by saying i have been a big supporter of Luke Brooks making his debut against the Dragons this week. This is not to "win games for the team", or "wasting his time". The reason i believe he must debut in 2013 is for his own confidence. To put the "it will effect the under 20's" talk to bed, I am saying he should play ONE NRL game. Our u20's play opposition who are 13th, 7th and 11th on the table to finish the season. The side is good enough to not have him for one week (after all, after 23 rounds he has only played 12 games due to injury and playing NSW Cup). This won't effect his eligibility for the Holden Cup finals series and with a player like Mulcahy on the bench, it won't effect the team's ability. In fact, as we saw with Koroibete last year, it may give him a huge boost for the finals.

My reasons for playing Luke Brooks run deeper than "avoiding the spoon", or "trying to save a sinking ship". Luke Brooks, in my opinion needs to have his debut prior to 2014. People don't realise that the focus all offseason will be about Luke Brooks. Papers and media outlets will have "The next Joey", "The player to replace benji", the media and fan pressure will be relentless (even more than what Adam Reynolds faced before his debut). Brooks is the 'real deal', players know that, coaches know that, the media knows that. It is imperative that Brooks debuts this year for his own confidence, as well as him being able to see first hand what parts of his game he needs to work on during preseason. Most of all he needs to debut this season or we face the prospect of the pressure valve exploding in his debut next year. Against the Dragons is a perfect opportunity, a no pressure game but a game in which he can still make his mark.

I must stress to fans that Luke Brooks will not dominate the NRL on debut, or early in his career. If you think this then you best adjust your expectations. He is a halfback that, at 18 years of age, has the maturity and knowledge of an experienced pro. He has a kicking game the club has missed since Scott Prince, he has the passing game (more importantly pass selection) that the team has lacked this year especially.

In 12 Holden Cup games, Luke Brooks has 12 tries, 8 Try Assists, 14 Line break assists, 8 Line breaks and 4 40/20's. He is the 'full package'. I have had the privilege of watching Brooks play live on a number of occasions, it is not the monster kick he has, or the accurate cut-out pass, it isn't his step and it isn't his creativity that impresses me. What impresses me most is the selections he makes during a game. He knows when to kick long, when to kick short, when to hit the front man or when to pass to the fullback sweeping around the back. Add to this his freakish ability of knowing when to run the footy. Sure he has games where he runs the ball less than 4 times, but in these games he averages at least one try. 

He is by no means a terrific defender, what he does have in defence though is courage, study Luke Brooks closely and you will see he doesn't choose to tackle the small opposition five-eighth or winger, he goes for the 110kg+ prop or rangy second rower. Because of this he misses 3 or 4 tackles a game but he plays well above his weight. 

A number of people who haven't seen Brooks play a lot believe Brooks is only good when Mitch Moses is playing in the halves with him....WRONG. It is true that Brooks and Moses have played in the halves together 7 times this year for a 6-1 win loss record but the reason there is this assumption is because they compliment each other so well. They know each others game very well, Brooks knows when to organise and play conservative and let Moses take a chance or to focus on a set play. After all Brooks, Moses and Sironen played in the same school team at Holy Cross Ryde, so they should have a good combination.

The first game i saw Luke Brooks play was before the ridiculous hype around him started. It was for Holy Cross Ryde and at this time all i knew about him was that he was in the Balmain and Wests Tigers setup. He didn't score a try that day, he didn't kick a 40/20, he didn't make line breaks. What he did was control a game like i have never seen a 17 year old control a game before. I am of the belief he reads the game better than any half at the club. Add to this the best kicking and passing game at the club and you can see why the club has huge plans for him.

Against the Broncos at Suncorp earlier this year the Holden Cup side was in all sorts of trouble. They were getting dominated in the forwards and were not making metres out wide. Brooks' ability to adapt to situations in games and adapt to his opposition turned the game on its head. As a lot of fans saw when the side played the Raiders, who had not lost in over 3 months. With the team trailing and under pressure, Brooks produced a stunning dropout which found touch and proceeded to score a matchwinning try. 
 
The hype around Luke Brooks first started when Andrew Johns and Brad Fittler saw him play. Johns spoke with Wayne Bennett about Brooks, and after watching Brooks for himself, the Knights offered a substantial contract to him at just 17 years of age. Andrew Johns has said a number of times that Luke Brooks is the first half to remind him of himself.

Will Luke Brooks live upto expectation?? I believe he will live upto the expectation I have for him, but i doubt he will live upto the expectation a number of fans have for him. Yes he is a tremendous young player, yes he could be the next Andrew Johns, yes he may be a superstar but as i saw tonight (20/08/13) some people have unfair expectations on young players. This means judging players by more than just highlight plays, or comparing them to a representative player in their position. Tedesco has 6 tries and 15 trysaves, as well as 5 try assists in his first season in the competition and fans were criticising him. Luke Brooks can take the NRL by storm, but fans need to have patience with him and not judge him on a handful of first grade games.

Tuesday 20 August 2013

The 2013 Files : Part 2 - Coaching/training

When Mick Potter accepted the job offer at Wests Tigers back in November 2012, i'm sure a lot of things went through his head. One of those thoughts would've been that "this is my big break". The chance to finally make it in his own field of dreams. The field of dreams that is the National Rugby League. One of many reasons for this being such a highly regarded field for league coaches is the bright lights that come with the job. It is where any league coach aspires to be. It is the top of the game. It is a job filled with pressure. The watching eyes of the league world wait, stalking, questioning, and analysing every move an NRL coach makes. The buck ultimately stops with coach.

In 2013 Mick Potter knew he was walking into a tough job at Wests Tigers. This club has always had its baggage. On top of that his predecessor Tim Sheens had spent ten years in Tigertown, moulding and shaping the club to his liking. Potter not only had assumed the squad of Sheens, but also had no chance to tailor the squad to his liking. That had already been taken care of. On top of that, Potter also assumed the assistants of Tim Sheens. Due to his late appointment, Potter opted to keep on the likes of Andrew Leeds, Steve Georgallis, Royce Simmons and John Skandalis amongst others.

The pre season began to reports that the Wests Tigers squad was training harder than ever before. Call that cliché, call it whatever you like. That statement never holds much weight. They all say it! Potter though mentioned that there were aspects of the club's on field performance that he would like to rectify. The defence was one of them. In fact it was the main concern. He wanted it tighter. He also wanted things tighter offensively. Not so much the opportunity to reign in an at times free spirited offense, but to be more selective on when to be more expansive. Potter noted that the attack certainly didn't need fine tuning.  However defence was the priority.

Fast forward now to late August, Round 24 in fact, and it's fair to suggest that no one could've predicted the 2013 season would go the way it has. Where to start? It has been a train wreck! A plethora of injuries has stagnated Mick Potter's attempts at building a cohesive first grade side. Potter's also had to deal with a serious lack of experience in the depth at the club. 8 rookies have debuted this season, several others came into this season with under 10 games experience. Potter's also had to deal with experienced players being out of form. Benji Marshall, Blake Ayshford, Chris Lawrence and Braith Anasta topping that list. Then there is the Benji Marshal soap opera. Lesson 101 in how to derail a football season.

So those above are the distractions. But what about the things that Potter has done? The good and the bad. Firstly to the good. In my opinion I don't think Potter has done half as bad as some are suggesting. Yes the Tigers are second last on the table with just 6 wins and just Parramatta below them but there's reason behind the struggles as mentioned above. Potter's had little choice but to give youth a chance. It's all that was there. Especially when the injuries hit. Inevitably though when youth is given a go it takes time before the best is seen. Potter's demeanour and approach though has been calm, firm and fair. You can see the likes of James Tedesco, David Nofoaluma, Tim Simona, Curtis Sironen, Jack Buchanan and Sauaso Sue are finding their feet and making strong contributions when the opportunity beckons. Potter's kept faith in these kids, he hasn't shot them down, any criticism has been constructive.

I often look for parallels between the Tigers and the Eels. I think their squads are somewhat similar. There's a smattering of decent talent. Some experience and a wealth of youth and inexperience.  Both clubs even has coaches in their first seasons at the club. Both sides sit next to each other on the bottom of the ladder, however this is where the similarities end. In my mind Potter has done a far better job that Stuart. Firstly, Potter's had to deal with more distractions thanks to injuries to senior players, boardroom squabbles and Benji Marshall's lack of form. The Eels have injuries too, not to the same extent though. They've also had issues with Chris Sandow. A closer look at the two teams though suggests Potter's been able to get more out of his young players than Stuart has at the Eels. I think his approach has been considerably better with the younger players too. Stuart appears impatient and in a hurry, Potter patient and measured.

Not all of Potter's work though has been great. Potter himself has admitted he's had issues in his communication with some of the younger players in the squad. His decision to bench Robbie Farah v Manly in the opening rounds was and still is a blip on his radar. There's been criticism regarding the Wests Tigers defence and attack. Both categories have us well down the list. The stats don't lie, its not been good enough. The jury though is out on Potter here due to the injuries suffered this season and the poor form of a key player in Marshall and the lack of effectiveness of the Tim Sheens recruit Braith Anasta.

Ultimately, looking forward to 2014 and the preying eyes of the league world will be expecting better of Potter. Assuming of course the season is not blighted by the same injury toll and player form, an improvement will be the minimum expectation. A more stabilized team sheet means an improvement in defence and attack is a must. Potter admitted that defence was high on the agenda when he arrived. He will get a chance to properly install a system to his liking this time. Potter and CEO Grant Mayer also desperately want to improve the training facilities, admitting the standards sit well below the bench mark in the NRL. This though may be more of a long term project. You also have to believe that the young guys will be better for this season's experience and it's an absolute must that Potter continues to aid their development, whether that be with the addition of some specialist coaching (the Tigers are believed to be sounding out Brad Fittler as a halves coach).

The rest will fall on Potter and his 2014 squad. I want to see improvement in the some of the little aspects of the game. The 1%'s of the game are just so critical. All the little extra efforts in defence and attack make up for a lot over the period of 80 mins. Without attention to detail one cannot simply expect his side to be near their best. The Melbourne's, Souths and Manly do it so well. Even the Roosters who last season struggled massively have turned it around this season. That must surely give the Wests Tigers some hope.

The challenge is now there for Potter and the Tigers. The potential is massive, but so are the obstacles in getting there

Monday 19 August 2013

Sterling delivers the truth on fallen Benji

"His heart isn't in it anymore. Something has to happen this week" - Andrew Johns on Benji Marshall's form

With that above statement comes the reality of the situation regarding the one time Golden Boot winner Benji Marshall.  His form has been criticised all season long by fans and experts. In recent weeks, say the past 2 months, that form has undeniably gotten worse for Marshall. So bad now that 2 of the games greatest halfbacks, Peter Sterling and Andrew Johns fail to see a way in which Marshall should be selected for upcoming matches.

Peter Sterling, one of the games great halfback's last night on Triple M Radio was asked if it was time for coach Mick Potter to make the tough call and drop Benji. His answer?...."I didn't think that but tonight has probably turned me to the fact that you can't keep him there for sentiment now. Just on form you drop him" Sterling said. "So wether he racks up 199 or 200 games at the club, that shouldn't come into it no" Sterling added. "It would have been nice to say that would be a lovely way to farewell and all those kind of things but in the end you have to put out 17 players every week who are going to give it their all and put their bodies on the line. I think there is probably another 17 in front of him at the moment who are prepared to do that." Sterling said.

Sterling was particularly critical of Benji's application, admitting the fallen star could've done a lot more for his side last night  "As I said at the time, when you pass the ball in this game you pass it to somebody in a better position to yourself. If there is nobody in a better position than yourself than you stick it under your arm, you put your head down and you take on the defence. We didn’t see that too often tonight. It’s not all about the runs. Forget the runs. When you go to the line to pass, I’m saying that it is all about putting your body on the line. The reason that I think he is struggling out there to get the support of the players is because when he takes the ball forward he passes well short of the line and says, 'well, here, you do it'."

"Benji is a good guy and he has done some great things for our game. He has held a very high profile. It’s sad but it has been so badly mishandled, the exit ... I just think he has got some really poor advice and he’s put himself in a position for criticism and all of the stuff he has done off the field, you can only do all of that if you back it up with what you show 80 minutes every week and he hasn’t done that." Sterling added.

It's a tragedy that it has come to this. Forget the fact that he's been poorly advised by his manager throughout this stupid fiasco. Forget the fact that just maybe Benji's ego has out grown it's limits in recent weeks. This whole thing only has partly to do with the mindset of a fallen champion who it's become painful to have to watch week in, week out lately. This comes back to the club and what's best for the club. In current form Marshall is no good for Wests Tigers. In fact his presence in the team seems to hinder the chances of the Tigers being successful in any match up.  Last week versus the Eels was the prime example. The Tigers should've won that game with ease but they failed to seriously build consistent pressure which meant they would chase the game for the larger portions of time. Marshall's bumbling ways - a big reason for the fact.

I get the feeling the players too have lost Confidence in Marshall. This is a player who in recent weeks has thrown more passes either forward, to ground or that simply weren't on and ended with an error. This is the same player that makes as many mistakes and he does forces mistake through poor passing. This is also the same player who doesn't take the line on anymore. The same guy who has failed to find touch from a penalty now 4 times this year!! You get the drift here??? His heart ISN'T in it any more. Neither is mind. His application has been dreadful in the past two months, his body language like wise.

The worst thing about it is having to listen to him in the press talk about his form and how he wants to go out on a high and how he's not happy with his form. I could choose to listen to him resonate his poor form and feel sorry for him as he tries to get it back, but I just don't see the signs that he's switched on and ready to turn the corner. Mentally he appears gone. Call it tired, jaded, exhausted....whatever. The bottom line is he will be a very fortunate guy to see the season out. His form doesn't warrant selection. He's been the undeniable flop of 2013.

Congratulations Benji!

Sunday 18 August 2013

A look ahead to Wests Tigers v Roosters

Lote Tuqiri tonight will make his first appearance of the 2013 NRL season. Troubled by a long term arm injury, Tuqiri's return will offer a sense of intrigue in to tonight's Monday Night Football clash in what otherwise looms as an unremarkable fixture.  The Roosters go into the clash joint leaders on the table and will take back sole leadership with a win at home in what is officially an away game at Allianz Stadium.

Tonight's clash marks a fixture where the Wests Tigers won't be given a chance of victory. Many will say the Roosters are too strong, too quick, too skilful and too confident to be beaten tonight, and they may well be right. For the Tigers, tonight's game represents another test and another chance to gain something to learn from. The challenge tonight will be on two fronts. Out wide and up the middle. The Roosters boast a bulky pack of forwards. The likes of Jared Waerea-Hargreaves, Sonny Bill Williams and Frank Paul Nuuausala threaten to tear the Tigers a new one tonight. With Jake Friend scheming behind at hooker and Mitchell Pearce and James Maloney calling the shots. This will the most serious test for the Tigers since their Round 11 clash vs Souths.

Out wide though there are further concerns for the Tigers. In attack the likes of Tim Simona and David Nofoaluma may provide their own threats, however defensively it is where the Tigers will worry. Daniel Tupou, Michael Jennings, Shaun Kenny Dowall and Roger Tuivasa-Sheck all have a minimum 8 tries or more each this season. Defense has not been anywhere near a good enough standard this season for the Tigers and tonight beckons a real serious test of their nerve.

If the Tigers are any chance tonight, as much as I hate to admit it, they will need the Roosters off their game and going through the motions. The Roosters simply look too strong. There is too much experience and too much quality to not take advantage of their situation tonight. The Tigers are in a rebuilding phase and it's unrealistic to expect great things tonight. If they can not present the Roosters with too many gifts and make the best with what they've got then perhaps they stay in the contest. Making the best of what they've got though means improvement from Benji Marshall and Braith Anasta in the halves. Whilst their experience is valuable, their form has not been valuable at all. Tonight these two must simply do better. In recent weeks it has been their mistakes which have put the side under added pressure. Tonight they can't afford to do that.

Ultimately, it's almost impossible to fathom the Tigers winning tonight. It will be tough, never say never though. You just never know.....

Thursday 15 August 2013

Potter's game plan


It's been a very tough introduction to the NRL for Wests Tigers coach Mick Potter. When he was told that this is a tough league with plenty of pressure, I'm fairly confident that those warning him had little knowledge of how 2013 would play out. Besieged by injuries, player discontent/poor form, board room squabble/leaks, Potter in no way could have fared any worse than he has this season. Last night, Potter was a guest on ONE's "The Game Plan", where he was interviewed by the Daily Telegraph's Dean Ritchie and given a fair grilling on the segment.

Straight off the top, Potter was asked: Does he deserve to be there??? "I think so. Under the circumstances....I feel I deserve another crack at it", Potter replied. Those circumstances have been such that the Tigers have fielded a side so short on experience, yet so high on youth - unlike any other side in the NRL in recent years. Those circumstances though do have a silver lining perhaps. As Potter admitted "I'm confident we can do a better job in 2014". Potter noted that the younger guys being thrown into the wolves now would be better for the experience next year and even better for the year after.

On his own future, Potter revealed that board members have assured him of his job next season. However as the show's host Andrew Moore suggested, there has to be concern for Potter's future given the noises suggesting so recently. At a club where leaks are all to common, enough smoke has surely gathered to fuel the fire. Potter admitted to not being naïve about his situation but when "a person tells me face to face that i'm in that position next year, i'd take him on face value. I don't believe they are liars. I think when someone looks you in the eye and tells you something, you believe them", Potter replied.

Potter admits that it's disappointing to hear these stories of him getting the sack, but admits that it doesn't influence what he does at the club. He is man of focus. Determined to continue building the clubs playing roster into an NRL competitive one. Potter is impressed and quietly confident at the roster he has, admitting that "the future is bright for the team, the fans and the club, we just need a bit of patience", Potter said. That patience is all about letting a largely youthful squad develop at it's  own pace.  Potter believe the players will all be better for this year's experience and expects an improvement in 2014, not only on a personal front but in the teams results, admitting he's very happy with talent coming through the system.

Potter also touched on several other issues of varying interests in the interview. Admitting that Benji's departure was more due to a contractual stand off with the club more than anything else. As for the rumours of senior players losing their support for him, Potter admits that "...when there's change and things aren't going along smoothly, people get a bit nervous and look for blame. The coach is an easy target".

 Potter is confident though in the job he is doing at the club, Clearly in a rebuilding phase, upheaval is inevitable. Many fans argued that the culture of the club needed change prior to Potter's arrival. It's safe to say that change is well and truly happening and as Potter himself said. We all need to show a little patience. I think most Wests Tigers fans understand that need for patience and that it would be incredibly harsh  if the club were to depart with Potter at the helm. Nothing in life is guaranteed though, but hopefully Mick's right when he takes the board for their word in regards to 2014.

Tuesday 13 August 2013

The 2013 Files - Part 1: Youth Development

Over the next 4 weeks Tiger Nation will present its own view on the health of the Wests Tigers. In a weekly look at the club, we'll focus on Youth development, Coaching philosophy, Boardroom/Admin and Supporters/home grounds. The idea being to assess the strengths, weaknesses and potential of each department as the Wests Tigers create their own new beginning.

Much has been said and done in the first 14 years of the joint venture. 2014 will mark our 15th season in the NRL. With only one Grand Final win to our name and a couple of other finals appearance, it's fair to say Wests Tigers have under achieved. The club though has done a lot of good off the field. Wests Tigers is today one of the country's leading sporting brands, both commercially with sponsors and in retail value.

Today's focus though is Youth Development. It seems for the past 3 or 4 years, the Wests Tigers have struck it lucky when it comes to finding a good quality youngster. In 2013 the Wests Tigers have found themselves in the best position youth wise since 2003. 2003 was the year that amongst others Robbie Farah, Benji Marshall and Liam Fulton all made their debuts for the club. This year the Tigers have debuted 8 players in total.

2013 Debuts

Sitaleki Akouola
Jack Buchanan
Jarred Farlow
Joel Luani
David Nofoaluma
Ava Seumanafagai
Shaun Spence
Sauaso Sue

The 2013 squad has also seen a group of players who themselves came into this season without even 10 games in the top grade prior.

Players with fewer than 10 game experience prior to 2013 season

Marika Koroibete
Jacob Miller (now of Hull)
Tim Simona
Curtis Sironen
James Tedesco
Sean Meaney

Further to that list, players such as Ben Murdoch-Masila and Aaron Woods, who have been around for 2-3 years, are still yet to reach their potential and have further development to come in the next couple of years.

You get the point here. That's 14 players on the books of Wests Tigers (not including Jacob Miller) who would still be considered young and with their best years in advance. Wests Tigers are clearly a young club. At one point this season the average age of the first grade team was just over 22 years old. Next season CEO Grant Mayer says the average age of the squad will be between 23-24 years old.

What we've seen here is a group of young players who aren't simply making up the numbers. Each one appears to have some potential in them. James Tedesco and Curtis Sironen were both injury replacements in the City Origin squad this season. Whilst it was perhaps before their time, it did show what regard the young duo were held in. Aaron Woods of course joined Robbie Farah in the NSW Origin team for two games. David Nofoaluma and Tim Simona have impressed on regular occasions this season. The work rate of Sauaso Sue and Jack Buchanan has been immense Curtis Sironen and Marika Koroibete possess the sort of talent that can't coached. Natual ability, The challenge for the club with all these youngsters is to get the best out of their potential. Below is summary of some of the key youngsters and a look ahead to what their futures may hold

James Tedesco

Past and Present
James Tedesco has been a real positive in 2013. Thrust into the spotlight back in round 1, 2012, Tedesco tore his ACL just 30 minutes in to the season and missed the entire 2012 season. So technically, 2013 is a debut year for the fullback. His play this season has been modest in attack. Having started the year on the wing, Tedesco shifted to fullback once Tim Moltzen ironically tore his ACL. The attacking flair of his junior days hasn't materialized yet but the revelation today that Tedesco has been playing with a broken bone in his leg supports a slightly subdued attacking performance in 2013. Defensively though He has been great. His performance in defence in recent weeks has been terrific. Highlighted by an exceptional performance against the Cowboys at a bogged Leichhardt Oval back in round 11.

The Future
Tedesco has shown enough to warrant being labelled the number 1 option at fullback long term. He shows all the basic necessary tools to become a top fullback. He can catch a high ball, his support play shows promise, his defensive positioning is usually spot on and he can tackle one on one like a good fullback should. You get the feeling with an injury free preparation for 2014 that he can only get better and better and begin to realize some of the promise he has shown. Best of all, the attacking skills should improve with time.


Curtis Sironen

Past and Present
Curtis Sironen thankfully appears to be one of those "Son of a gun" types who will forge his own path in the NRL. Sironen's experience in the NRL has seen him amass a few games in 2012 and around 3 quarters of the 2013 season (after a delayed start to 2013 due to a shoulder reconstruction). His time so far has seen him play mostly in the halves. Whilst he hasn't set the world on fire by any means, he appears to have the attributes to become a real player in the second row. Height and weight wise, Sironen sits along Sonny Bill Williams and it appears he's destined to play a similar role for the Tigers possibly as early as next season.

The Future
Sironen WILL end up in the back row. He is destined for it. His height, mobility and strength mean he will be a real weapon there moving forward. Coach Mick Potters reckons he's not far off now. In recent weeks Sironen has spent more time in the back row, in preparation for a full time switch. My reckoning suggests to watch this space in the next 12 months. You get the feeling he will come on real strong.


Tim Simona

Past and Present
Tim Simona actually made his debut back in 2011, as a slightly built centre vs the Knights at Leichhardt Oval. Only a few appearances followed under coach Tim Sheens. That was until this season when a crippling injury toll that claimed Blake Ayshford and Chris Lawrence amongst others gave Simona his chance. A breakout game against the Panthers in round 13 set the tone for Tim to become the best performing back at the club in 2013 with 8 tries in 13 games so far. Simona's speed and acceleration have been a joy to watch.

The Future
2014 will see Simona most likely become a key cog in the Tigers attack. Whether he plays centre of wing remains to be seen. Simona though brings speed and an ability to finish a try. With a bit of luck, his trajectory will continue to rise.



Marika Koroibete

Past and Present
Marika Koroibete is exactly what any club dreams of having. A powerfully built, speedy winger who knows no fear. Marika's potential has massive upside for a guy with such minimal footballing experience. He's definitely a work in progress. Defensively he has things to work on, such as catching the high ball and reading the oncoming traffic headed his way. He announced himself in stunning fashion versus the Eels back in 2012 when he scored 4 tries in one game with some powerful and blistering running. 2013 hasn't been quite so productive. He's still looked an asset in attack but injuries have stalled his progress for now.

The Future
Koroibete definitely has a future in the NRL. Hopefully that remains at the Tigers. He's under contract for next season but you get the feeling his development will dictate his future. He's rocks and diamonds right now. So long as he shows improvement, there's no reason he won't follow the path of Uate of the Knights and become a real force.



Sauaso Sue

Past and Present
Sauaso is a Wests Magpies junior who has hit the ground running with some strong performances in his debut season. Sauaso is known for some strong, mobile ball running and an impressive workrate in defence. Off the field and the coaching staff have praised his commitment and professionalism.

The Future
Sauaso appears to have a great future at the club. For someone who possesses such on field ability, mixed with a determination and professionalism off the field and on the training paddock, you feel the sky is endless. I suspect he'll become a mainstay of the pack in the years ahead.


David Nofoaluma

Past and Present
David's NRL career has hit the ground running and ended up with try after try. That's how well he's done. 8 tries in 11 games in a debut season is an exceptional record. The manner of his tries is equally impressive. Highlighted no doubt by the NFL-esque try he scored a few Monday night's back versus the Sea Eagles. Most impressively, Nofoaluma has basically replicated his NYC form in the higher standard of the NRL. Which means he's making 5-6 tackle busts a game and usually well in excess of 100 metres a game too. He has a proven a VERY reliable finisher.

The Future
Sky appears the limit for David. For a guy of just 19 years of age, his potential has massive upside. He'll get quicker, stronger and smarter yet.  He also has the ability to play in the centres and with his tackle breaking ability, this may be where he ends up on a permanent basis.


Jack Buchanan

Past and Present
Jack joined the Wests Tigers from the Dragons this season. He was thrust into a starting role after Aaron Woods missed the beginning of the season with injury. A further injury to Keith Galloway meant Buchanan was doing the work of a seasoned veteran.  I thought he did his job well. Naturally his performances fell a little but for a guy with so little first grade behind him, it was admirable. To this point late in his debut season, Jack's proving ever reliable and he looks a keeper.

The Future
The future looks real healthy for Jack. His workrate is good and his frame suggests that once he fills out, he will continue to be an asset. His hard work and desire are good signs that he's switched on a ready to make a name for himself.




2014

There's little doubt that 2013 will mark the end of one era and herald in the beginning of another. With the high profile departure of Benji Marshall, the Tigers will almost obtain a new identity. An identity that will centre in on the young guns. The players I featured above will be vital in the next few years. The Tigers though will benefit from another influx of youth. Already dynamic halves duo Luke Brooks and Mitchell Moses have been touted as the long term future stars for the club. Others though will play their part. Hooker Joel Luani who's debuted this season, figures to play a bigger role. The young 20 year old will be Robbie Farah's understudy and the man most likely to assume his mantle in the long term.

 Of the others, the Wests Tigers U20's Nathan Brown, Kyle Lovett, Manaia Rudolph and Kurtis Rowe all look like potential first graders. Then there's the SG Ball group. Balmain has won the past two SG Ball titles and National titles, whilst the Wests Magpies also made the finals this year. Names such as Rhys Armstrong, Matt Woods and even Benji Marshall younger brother Jeremy are names with much promise.

2014 and Beyond

Wests Tigers CEO Grant Mayer has already indicated much faith will be placed on the ability to nurture and further develop the young players coming through the system. It is vitally important that the results of this current "coaching structure review" highlight the ability to best nurture these young players in order to harness their talents and to enhance their abilities. The future success of Wests Tigers relies on getting this process correct. Ultimately the club needs to look at long term investment of an academy, most likely in the Campbelltown region. Ideally such an academy would allow the club to continue to foster the needs of its young players and enhance their abilities. It would also tie much valuable resources for Wests Tigers in a growing catchment area of Western Sydney. The upside potential here is enormous!

To matters more in real time, the Wests Tigers have now invested a lot of time into their youth for the past 5 or 6 years, perhaps longer. Now is the time for the club to solidify that commitment. The time has come for the club to say that this is they way we do it. In 2014 the like of James Tedesco, Tim Simona, David Nofoaluma, Curtis Sironen, Marika Koroibete, Sauaso Sue and Jack Buchanan will be relied upon more than ever. More will also be expected of them all. This though is not a one way street. In order for their talents to flourish, those "coaching structure review" results will be key. We have to get it right. We can't afford to get it wrong and watch these talents stall. Hopefully the results of this commitment continue to bare fruit. If it does, Wests Tigers will reap the rewards and turn the next 15 years into a polar opposite of their first 15 years.

Over to you Mick Potter. Good luck!


Monday 12 August 2013

Fan backlash to save Potter??

The latest developments surrounding the future of Wests Tigers coach Mick Potter this morning seem to indicate the likelihood of the embattled coach being kept on in 2014. Since Thursday's carefully worded official club statement and the loss on field to the Eels the following day, Potter's position appears to have become more certain after a series of interviews involving club CEO Grant Mayer.

Several interviews have been conducted over the past few days with appearances on ABC Radio, Triple M and an interview with the Daily Telegraph's Dean Ritchie. The series of interviews have shed light on the outlook for coach Potter, or seemingly have anyways. This morning's latest interview has seen Mayer state in regards to Potter remaining at the helm in 2014....

"Absolutely. He has a contract for 2014 and I have no doubt that he will be here"

Mayer follows this up with regards to speculation that it will be the board that punts him.....

"There are two areas the joint venture board agree on - the CEO and the coach. In this instance, the CEO is appointed, that's me, and the coach is here till the end of next season. I have no reason to think that will change."

Mayer later states that the board has given every indication that Potter will be here in 2014. The trouble with the above is that it's still not a guarantee that Potter will 100% be here in 2014. We will simply have to trust that what they say is gospel. However the club will no doubt be fully aware of the fan backlash they can expect if Potter is moved on. Some sections of the media have noted this as a factor that could well see Potter retain his job when it was so close to slipping out of his grasp.

Wests Tigers fans have been strong in their disapproval. Many have threatened to back out of retaining club memberships for 2014 if he were to be moved on. The general consensus is that Potter deserves the chance to have a full crack at the NRL. In 2013 Potter has inherited a squad that was not his and a coaching staff that was Tim Sheens. The theory is that if Potter is given what he wants by the club then the process should be smoother and results on the field a little easier to digest.

Mick Potter - Unfinished Business

Via. @NothingButWT
 
In less than 12 months Mick Potter has faced more hurdles than Tim Sheens did in 10 years. Firstly let's compare Tim Sheens' first year with Mick Potter's.

When Tim Sheens took over from Terry Lamb the club had just finished 13th in a 15 team competition. Sheens was forced to blood eleven, yes eleven debutants in his first year. His win loss record finished identical to that of Terry Lamb's in 2002, 7 wins and 17 losses and again the club finished in 13th place.

In that eventful year of 2003 we saw the debuts of Robbie Farah, Benji Marshall, Dene Halatau, Dean Collis, Luke Covell, Liam Fulton, Bryce Gibbs, Chris Heighington, Clint Hill, Adam Tippett and Gray Viane.

Even the crowd numbers were similar to what the club has experienced in 2012/2013. In 2002, Terry Lamb's last season as head coach, the club averaged 10,478 for home games. In Tim Sheens' first year crowds were down to under 9,000. But surely you couldn't sack Tim Sheens after finishing third last, blooding 11 debutants and seeing crowd numbers drop?

Sheens spent the offseason looking back on a season which would struggle to get a pass mark. Similar to what Mick Potter may face with the NRL 9's if he gets a second year, Tim Sheens made his first statement to Wests Tigers fans and the NRL in 2004 (second year in charge) by guiding the club to the World Sevens Championship. Sheens and the team followed this up with a 9th placed finish in 2004 and from that point, we know what followed in 2005. 

The main reason it appears some fans and players want Potter relieved from his duties is his communication skills.

"Mick Potter has extremely poor communication skills and players are fed up."

Ironically, when Tim Sheens arrived at the Wests Tigers there was question marks in the media and among Cowboys fans about his reportedly poor communication skills. From people in North Queensland saying he arrived at training via a helicopter, speaking with his assistants while the team were put through their paces, to leaving training having not said a word to any player throughout the session.

Sheens and Potter had similar first years in charge, scarily similar you might say. Would 2005 have happened for the Wests Tigers if a new coach was blooded at the end of 2003 when the club was seemingly treading water, and to a point, close to drowning? Would a new coach have had the confidence to develop and believe in players like Farah and Marshall? Would he have even rated them as footballers?

 We have always been a team known for its 'razzle dazzle', but we have always been known as a 'soft' team when it comes to grinding games out. I personally think Potter can be the man to shake this tag. We have seen it in spurts, with the Storm game as a prime example. A young team, on a miserable night showing THAT steely resolve that is required.

A large section of Wests Tigers fans, and footy fans in general believe Mick Potter deserves to see out his contract and show what he can do. In 2013, he has been the coach who has suffered the most setbacks by a country mile. But what setbacks could derail a club who were favourites to win the competition just 12 months prior?

Potter was handed the coaching role a week before preseason, at a club that, on the surface, seemed to be one that valued loyalty for a large part of its existence. Sheens had 11 seasons as head coach and made the semifinals 3 times. The club showed unbelievable loyalty and patience to Benji Marshall by keeping him at the club through multiple shoulder reconstructions, even though at the time he was a kid that had only showed glimpses of being a future superstar.

Potter's first job was to enter a pre-season with another coach's roster and get them prepared for a big season after falling from Premiership favourites to mid table obscurity. Potter was also handed Tim Sheen's backroom coaching staff which were hired just weeks prior to Sheens getting the chop.

There was no touch footy, no comedy skits, just a squad of footy players putting their best foot forward. Comments from players made it appear that they were buying into Potter's style and Potter's mindset. Many said it was by far the hardest they have worked, and have been worked in a pre-season at the club. Comments like this left fans with a "new start" feel about the club and team.

From this point the tasks Mick Potter faced left him fighting a losing battle.

The trials were finished, there was a nervous energy sweeping through the fans, and players were preparing for a big start to the year when we were all hit with the news that one of our most promising and popular juniors Mosese Fotuaika had passed away on the 28th of February. The club was bombarded with fans offering their messages of support for the members of Mosese's family, players and staff. We read articles from Todd Payten that he considered forfeiting Round 1 and we witnessed our club and players unite as one and put aside their footy commitments to travel to Brisbane to farewell their teammate, friend and brother.

On their return, Potter was faced with the task of getting his squad focused and ready to play Round 1 against the Knights. His task was made harder by a Knights team who had hit the ground running.

If this was a challenging start to an NRL coaching career, he was unaware that it was only going to get harder.

Over the 22 completed rounds of footy the club, has faced 40+ injuries which have resulted in players missing a minimum of one game. So far in season 2013, the Wests Tigers squad combined has missed over 100 first grade games due to injury.

This not only impacted the squad Potter had, but also the calibre of replacements he could call on. The lack of " NRL ready" depth left to Potter from 2012 became evident as players dropped like flies. Potter was forced to call on debutants and rookies and 'throw them in the deep end' together. Overall, Potter has used 8 debutants, as well as using a handful of players with less than 10 NRL games experience. At times he admitted that a number of the young players were not ready for the step up to the NRL. A positive to the injury crisis the club faced in 2013 was the emergence of Holden Cup star David Nofoaluma, new recruit Jack Buchanan, Junior Kiwi Sauaso Sue, Toyota Cup winning captain Jacob Miller and 2012 Balmain NSW Cup prop Ava Seumanufagai. As well as consistent opportunities for Tim Simona and chances for Holden Cup eligible players Curtis Sironen and James Tedesco to regain their spots in the top grade after injury. The injury toll also gave opportunities to Sitaleki Akaoula, Shaun Spence, Jarred Farlow and Joel Luani. There is no doubt that a different and further depleted 17 every week impacted on the coach and players. This season Jack Buchanan and Adam Blair are the only two players to have played in all 20 games.

To illustrate just how bad the injury toll was on the club, in a "NSW Cup" preseason trial, the Wests Tigers side contained David Nofoaluma, James Tedesco, Tim Simona, Jack Buchanan, Jarred Farlow, Bodene Thompson, with Shaun Spence, Sitaleki Akaoula and Sauaso Sue on the bench and Ava Seumanufagai unable to get a spot in the side. 

The "patched together squad" then endured a record losing streak including a 54-10 annihilation against the Bunnies. A week later we saw a great last minute win against the Cowboys which had the team pumped, and it appeared the players were finally starting to buy into Potter's goals and plans.

Just as it all seemed to be turning around for the club, Potter was dealt another blow with with CEO Stephen Humphreys stepping down from his position and Warren McDonnell moved on from the Recruitment Manager role. To his credit Potter rolled with the punches again and Grant Mayer took over as COO of the club. From day one of Mayer's appointment it appeared the club was heading in the right direction. Soon Mayer was offered (and accepted) the CEO role at the club. 

Before Grant Mayer could sit down he was hit with the "soap opera" that was Benji Marshall's contract negotiations. These negotiations have visibly had an impact on the squad and Marshall himself and the current five game losing streak coincided with the "contract saga" that was handled poorly and was played out in the media spotlight. 

Potter now finds himself with a number of under performing (possibly disinterested players) in the side. Having used 31 players in 22 rounds of footy means his hands are tied when it comes to finding replacements. 

I won't go into the "clashes" with Benji Marshall or any other reported problems at the club at this time but i will say this, his decision in Round 10 to drop Benji Marshall will be a blessing in disguise for the young crop of players moving forward. Under Mick Potter no one's position is safe, regardless of what is on your CV. 

I personally am excited to see what 2014 and beyond holds for the club. Look at the signings Potter, Mayer and the club have made for next year. They aren't superstars who expect to be selected every week, they aren't players who have to have their heads on TV or in the papers every day. They are footballers who all have one thing in common, they are desperate for another chance in the NRL. Richards, Lulia, Paterson are desperate to return to the NRL after stints in the UK. Blake Austin and Marty Taupau have found themselves down the pecking order at their respective clubs and we will see Dene Halatau return, a player built on culture, leadership and work ethic.

A mix of youth and hard work will put us in good stead for 2014 and beyond.

The club has been screaming out for a coach like Mick Potter. Hard nosed, uncompromising and an 'i am your coach, not your best mate' attitude. Under Mick Potter in 2014 we might finally see the word 'accountability' used within the footy team and within the club itself. 

Keep Mick Potter at the helm in 2014, the guy deserves a chance, and hopefully after reading this you will see why i think he has done a damn good job considering their position on the table, as well as seeing that Sheens endured the same tough start to his coaching career at the club.

Sunday 11 August 2013

Benji......cares???

So at what point does Benji Marshall begin caring again? We've heard for weeks a player who is "sad to be leaving" or wants to "give it my best shot for the fans". So far though we've yet to see it. There is plenty of talk suggesting Marshall has lost interest already, that he can't wait to move on from what has been a most difficult stint in the departure lounge. The way it's ending, Wests Tigers fans almost feel the same way.

Benji Marshall has been the pin up boy at Wests Tigers forever, people associate the Tigers with Benji and Benji like wise with the Tigers. His achievements at the club are exceptional and it was always going to be hard to see him go. However the past 2 months have tainted that legacy. I don't see the passion in his eyes anymore and his body language suggests he's struggling to fathom any motivation to play his way out of a horrific form slump. His decision on the weekend to parade himself in an Auckland Blues jumper may not have seemed a big issue. Consider this though. Marshall did that without any permission from his current employer. Not only did he endorse a rival code and teams colours, but Marshall who's current NRL deal includes lucrative third party sponsorships chose to endorse sponsors other than those he is currently paid by. To call it unprofessional would be true. Given recent events, would it be fair to call it arrogant and intentional?

It brings me back to my original point. At what point does Benji Marshall begin caring again?? His form on the field suggests he's stopped caring. His decision making off field suggests the same thing. He offered another insight into his mindset in the now infamous Auckland Blues video, when he thanked his fans but made no mention of the Wests Tigers or any support staff his career has been developed with. No thanks for a club that stuck by him and kept faith in during his low points. Some would call this another sign of an egotistical Marshall, still smarting from having his retirement package taken off the table at Wests Tigers. Maybe he does have a point to a degree but his reaction to it was childish and his actions since equally childish.

I want it known also that i'm okay with Marshall's defection to rugby. After all, he's entitled to make his own decision. However when it comes to assessing the way he has handled this whole chapter I will admit that I've lost respect for him. His name now comes with a badly tainted asterix next to it. Marshall has spent a lot of time blaming others for his demise when in actual fact he's handled it no better, if not worse. To call him a petulant brat wouldn't be harsh. It's fair to say he's thrown his toys out of the cot.

So back to my original point. When will Benji Marshall begin caring again? Most likely never and sadly for some Wests Tigers fans including myself, I cannot wait to see the back of him.

Thursday 8 August 2013

Wests Tigers board with a hell of a lot to explain!

News that Wests Tigers will at some point part way with coach Mick Potter continues to gather momentum this morning. Various sources, some high profile, have suggested Potter will be terminated from his job at the Tigers at some point this month. However, this has got me asking one vital question.

Rumours have been rife for 3-4 months that factions within the Wests Tigers boardroom have been on Potter's case. The question that needs to be asked is that if Potter was causing distress for the boardroom as early as then, then surely there has to be some extreme doubt over the board's decision to appoint Potter in the first place. Did they do their research properly? Surely they knew the kind of man they were getting?? As it stands now in August, i'm beginning to think they didn't?? One has to ask it then. If Potter is terminated from his role as coach, then surely it's only fair to ask those of the board involved to move on as well. After all, it was their involvement in what now appears in their eyes a poor and botched appointment. An appointment that would cost the club more money after a failed sacking attempt with previous coach Tim Sheens.

 This was a critical appointment. Getting it wrong and giving up on Potter now is a disaster! My question is - Why is Potter the only one accountable?? For a board to get such a critical appointment wrong, albeit with the benefit of hindsight, their positions should be rightly questioned. They have failed their coach, their players, their stakeholders, sponsors and most importantly the fans of the club. All at a time where it was critical they made the right appointment. Potter was their product. If he is made to walk, well shouldn't others follow suit??

Wednesday 7 August 2013

3 members of Wests Tigers coaching staff to move on at years end.

Wests Tigers this morning released a statement announcing that 3 members of Mick Potter's support staff will not have their contracts extended beyond 2013.  Whilst the names of the trio have not been formally offered, it's also noted that coach Mick Potter's future remains none the wiser after the release of the said statement.

Last night Twitter went into over drive for Wests Tigers fans after a tweet from Rugby League Week's "The Mole" suggested Potter would be punted in the near future. A #SavePotter hash tag then ensued with the overwhelming belief that sacking Potter would be like reversing a semi into lake. The argument for Potter to stay has been done on here before, summarised below as:

- Potter's arrival in November meant he had no say in the shaping of the 2013 playing roster.

- His late arrival also meant it best he stuck with the same coaching personnel as Tim Sheens. He also opted to press ahead with the already organised pre season plans for 2013.

- A playing roster that looked noticeably short on NRL experience in regards to its depth. The top 17 were fine, outside of that was different story. The problem here surfaced once an horrific injury toll on senior players kicked in. Wests Tigers then lost 7 games on the trot.

- Benji Marshall.  Marshall has handled this entire situation about as well as an 8 year old kid with a spoilt brat attitude. Pathetic really. I've got no doubts that he's behind the player power that has raised concerns about Potter's management. In a season where the Tigers really could've used the talent of Marshall, his form has been at an all time low. Even 18 year old Benji was better than the current one. The form of other key players has also hurt Potter's reputation this season.

- Boardroom drama. Which way are Wests Tigers heading? Granted that the situation has improved since Grant Mayer's appointment as CEO, but prior to that it was a rabble and factions in the boardroom remain a real hindrance to the club.

For all of the above though, it won't matter. Ultimately the board at Wests Tigers will judge the coach however they want. Suggestions that players aren't happy with Potter's management will no doubt be investigated. I don't doubt the club will investigate it all thoroughly. The problem for us fans is that we are outside looking in. It's hard for us to say too much of any sense. From here it seems any parting of ways with Potter would be harsh, unfortunate, crazy, absurd, suicidal and over the top.  At the end of the day though we'll just need to trust the club. I don't think they want to pay out yet another coach, so any decision made is one that will simply have to be trusted and accepted no matter how much biting of the tongue will be required.

This morning's statement does little to convince anyone that Potter will be staying. It's carefully worded to perceive that there is no decision to be made regarding Potter's future.........yet, but there's also nothing to suggest he won't be sacked at some point in the future. It appears in my view that the club has either already made a decision which has not been made publically, or that they will take the final month of the season to monitor the situation.

I'll finish by saying this though, this morning the waters have just become a little murkier. Potter best be prepared for the worst.

Tuesday 6 August 2013

2 more in at Wests Tigers as 2014 takes shape

Wests Tigers today confirmed the signings of Hull KR backrower Cory Patterson (1 yr) and Penrith Panthers utility Blake Austin (2 yrs). The duo's signing makes it six new faces added to the roster for next season.  26 year old Patterson, a former Knights and Cowboys player, returns to the NRL due to his wife experiencing home sickness. Austin, a 22 year old Panthers junior was highly regarded a few years back but has seemingly fallen off the radar at the foot of the mountains.

Austin and Patterson represent a familiar trend in the Wests Tigers 2014 recruits. All new signings are looking to prove themselves in new surrounds. These additions appear largely signings made in order to create depth. Pat Richards, Cory Patterson, Martin Taupau and Dene Halatau should all be safe bets for the final 17 come round one. Blake Austin and Keith Lulia could be there, but circumstances will dictate that. Both will start as back up players in their respective positions. Below are some thoughts on the Tigers 2014 recruits and just where they may fit into the plans in Tiger town.

Martin Taupau 

There's no denying Martin has the ability to cut it in the NRL. He's big, strong, rangy and aggressive. These are key attributes for any front rower. Taupau looked to be forging his way at the Bulldogs, however the arrival of James Graham and the emergence of Sam Kasiano pushed Taupau down the pecking order and he's had barely a look in since. Taupau will get his chance at Wests Tigers where he'll likely start from the bench in a forward rotation along side Aaron Woods and Keith Galloway. This should prove valuable due to the impact Taupau will bring. His strong running is hoped to provide an injection to the forward pack once the initial interchanges occur.


Pat Richards

Pat Richards return to the NRL is seen by many as one last hurruh for the hulking back. Able to play fullback, centre and wing. Richards returns to Wests Tigers after winning a title with the club back in 2005. Since then Richards has been excelling in a big, big way in the English Super League. Constantly up there in point scoring categories, Richards has made a stunning impact in England. His return to the Tigers is likely to see him slot in either in the centres or the wing. Richards is also likely to assume the goal kicking in 2014 off departing Benji Marshall. His experience will be vital in a squad where according to Grant Mayer will be roughly 23-24 years old.


Dene Halatau

Dene Halatau, like Pat Richards, returns to Wests Tigers after spending recent years with the Canterbury Bulldogs. Halatau, a premiership winner with Wests Tigers saw limited game time with the Bulldogs due to an impressive back rotation that included Greg Eastwood, Frank Pritchard and in recent years Tony Williams and Josh Jackson. Halatau returns with a point to prove. Many Tigers fans were sad to see him leave so his return will be pleasing, even if only for sentimental reasons. Tigers CEO Grant Mayer confirmed that Halatau's signing was a significant one. His leadership and  work ethic a BIG reason as to why he was bought back. It's hoped that Dene's experience will benefit the host of youngsters within the club's ranks.


Keith Lulia

At 26, Keith Lulia will provide more experience for a young Wests Tigers squad in 2014. Previous stints with Bradford, Newcastle and St George have shown Lulia to be a more than capable centre who will add depth for the Tigers. Whether he has the ability to challenge the young brigade at Wests Tigers remains to be seen. Lulia though will keep his competitors honest. In Lulia's favour though is the fact that he's already spent time under coach Mick Potter at Bradford, so Potter obviously believes he can do a job here. He's yet another player looking to prove a point.


Cory Patterson

Cory Patterson is just the kind of forward Wests Tigers were looking for. A rangy, strong running, hard tackling back rower. He may be a poor man's Gareth Ellis, but that's not meant to be a bad thing, because this is something the Tigers know they could use. Patterson signs for 1 season but you get the feeling that will be extended at some point, so long as his form is there. Patterson's previous experience at the Knights and Cowboys means he'll be ready and super keen to make an impact next season, and he'll know what to expect.


Blake Austin

Touted as a real player of the future only a couple of years back, Blake Austin makes the move from Penrith in search of opportunity. I'm not really sure why it never worked at the Panthers but Austin could well provide some value for the Tigers. For starters his utility value is enormous, having spent time at centre, 5/8, halfback and lock. Austin will most likely provide another option in the halves where it's expected that Luke Brooks will work with one of either Braith Anasta or Curtis Sironen.  If he impresses in pre season I see no reason why Austin can't get a crack in there either.


Wests Tigers name 8th debutant of 2013 season

Another injury to Wests Tigers captain Robbie Farah has paved the way for another rookie to debut in first grade this weekend versus the Eels. Young hooker Joel Luani will replace the NSW Origin rake in a side that is fast looking like the Wests Tigers 2012 Toyota Cup team. Luani replaces Farah who will be missing for 1-2 weeks with a fractured finger/knuckle. 

In other changes, young Fijian winger Marika Koroibete returns to first grade in a backline shuffle due to the premature end of centre Chris Lawrence's season with an ankle injury that requires surgery. Lawrence's position in the centres goes to winger Tim Simona.

There was no room (yet) for 18 year old half back Luke Brooks who would need to gain an exemption from the NRL due to the Tigers maxing out their second tier salary cap. Although some suggestions point to Brooks being a late addition in a bid to shield any possible debut till late notice.

Wests Tigers also confirmed today that in addition to Chris Lawrence's season ending injury, he will be joined by prop Aaron Woods who will also miss the remaining rounds with knee surgery on the cards. The latest injuries are yet another insult in a season of mass destruction at Wests Tigers.

Sunday 4 August 2013

Off season where art thou??

Yesterday's loss for the Wests Tigers may not have been the biggest of the season but there's no denying the fact that it was in my opinion, the worst loss of the season.  The Tigers performance against a patched up Gold Coast side was so insipid that fans were left wondering if some players had even bothered. Such was the ease that the Titans did everything, the Tigers didn't seem to offer more than just a speed bump.

The reality for the Tigers was that yesterday's game was a definite winnable game. The Titans were undermanned with key personnel missing. In fact, it would be fair to suggest that the Titans were worse off than the Tigers. The only key player missing for the Tigers was Aaron Woods. Missing for the Titans were Albert Kelly, Will Zillman, Matt Srama and Luke Bailey amongst others. With that, the Tigers had a stronger side out on the park yesterday.

Much will be made of yesterday's performance, the Tigers made a lot of rookie mistakes in both defence and attack but it was a deeper, more troublesome underlying problem at the centre of the issue yesterday. The application of some senior players was poor. Real poor! Fans can cop a loss, or players who simply had a bad day, so long as the effort is there. However yesterday a couple of senior Wests Tigers showed little commitment to the cause yesterday. Benji Marshall and Blake Ayshford just didn't look interested yesterday. Their work rates were poor, their effectiveness measured in how much their lack of effort hurt their team by the end of the game. The signs were there from the start. Neither player's body language suggested they were up for the game.  Defensively Ayshford was as horrible as Marshall was horrible in attack.

The trouble with their performance is that in a young team it's the performance of senior players that encourages the younger players to follow suit. They are the examples. Some did their job. Adam Blair, Liam Fulton and Keith Galloway tried their best. Chris Lawrence who had an unhappy game also deserves to be noted for his efforts. Some of the youngsters also played well. James Tedesco was without question the Tigers best. However in order for them to improve, they need the encouragement of the senior players, they need to see the experienced players perform, doing the little things right. Yesterday some of those senior players let them down in a big way.

The week ahead for the Tigers now shapes as an interesting one. Not least because coach Mick Potter has suggested he'll talk with the NRL about an exemption for young halfback Luke Brooks. The week will also be interesting in relation to what Potter does with his team overall. There will be huge pressure on Blake Ayshford to hold his spot after Sunday. His performance just wasn't acceptable. Young winger Marika Koroibete could return, shifting Tim Simona to the centre. Much question will focus on Benji Marshall again whose performance since announcing his departure has been horrible. His application has been poor and he's look far from switched on. Would Potter dump him to the bench again?? I wouldn't rule it out. There has to be some possibility that Luke Brooks could team up with Braith Anasta this week against the Eels.

One thing though is certain, I think the season is catching up with the Tigers and is taking a toll. Mentally this side has absorbed a lot. From the death of Mosese Fotuiaka before the season even started, to the 7 match losing streak and horrendous injury toll.  Chuck in the Benji Marshall drama, a boardroom squabble and quite a lot has happened. The off season cannot come soon enough.



Thursday 1 August 2013

The case for Mick Potter

Speculation this week has surrounded the future of Wests Tigers coach Mick Potter. Whether fair or unfair, Potter's position has been questioned in some quarters in the wake of the Tigers winning just 6 of 18 matches this season.  At the start of the season, the Tigers lost a club record 7 matches in a row, hardly helping their cause or their coach's.

The truth though is that there is method behind the madness that has ensued this season. Wests Tigers already came into this season with a younger squad than last season. Avg. age of the squad in 2013 was 25. That will drop to just 23 next season according to club CEO Grant Mayer. However this hasn't been the sole reason for their poor form this season. The club battled a horrendous injury toll early in the season that claimed long term casualties including Lote Tuqiri, Keith Galloway, Chris Lawrence, Blake Ayshford,Tim Moltzen and Matt Bell. Now that's just the experienced players. Others including Marika Koroibete have also faced long stints whilst shorter stints on the sideline also plagued the likes of Benji Marshall, Braith Anasta, Robbie Farah, Aaron Woods and James Tedesco. To call that injury toll horrendous may in fact be an understatement.

The trouble with the above injury toll wasn't just the fact injuries hit hard. It was to the wrong players. Mostly experienced players. The Wests Tigers plight was made worse by the fact that the squad was a young one to begin with. A look at the NSW Cup squad also revealed a lack of experience, meaning much of the guys called into first grade to replace the likes of seasoned rep players in Tuqiri, Galloway and Lawrence were rookies such as Shaun Spence, Sauaso Sue, Ava Seumanafagai and David Nofoaluma. In fact the average age of both the NRL and NSW Cup sides was just 22 at one point.

What we start to realize is that Mick Potter has been dealt an extremely tough and challenging initiation in 2013. Wests Tigers have released a host of experienced names in the past two seasons. Headlined by Bryce Gibbs, Andrew Fafita, Chris Heighington, Beau Ryan and the Cronulla Tiger-Sharks. Chuck in the loss of Englishmen Gareth Ellis and that's a tongue of experience! Replaced only moderately by an at first disappointing Adam Blair, Braith Anasta and Eddy Pettybourne to name a few. Of those 3, only Blair has shown any resemblance of good form and even that has only come in the past 2 months. His first season was real underwhelming and his early form in 2013 was not any better.

To make matters even worse for Potter, not only has he had to deal with relying on a squad that is inexperienced more than it is experienced. Potter's also had to deal with the poor form of arguably his most talented player, Benji Marshall. Marshall's form in 2013 has been well, well documented. It's been poor! Adam Blair was in a similar funk through till June but has looked much better since. Having had to rely on such a young squad has its challenges, having that coincide with the poor form of some of your most experienced players, Braith Anasta and Eddy Pettybourne included, has only made it worse.

However, it's not all gloom for the Tigers. A host of the young players have stepped up and shown significant improvement from earlier in the season. In fact some have settled right in, David Nofoaluma, Tim Simona and Sauso Sue have shown they've got tremendous futures if their willing to continue to work hard. This trio possess talent beyond what was expected of them.

Others including James Tedesco, Curtis Sironen, Marika Koroibete, Jack Buchanan and Ava Seumanafagai have all improved over the course of the season, giving hope that they too can be relied on moving forward. For this Mick Potter deserves credit and plenty of it.  In a tough situation Potter has turned rocks into potential diamonds. Sure the leadership of players such as Robbie Farah, Benji Marshall, Braith Anasta and Aaron Woods can only help the young guys too, but Potter can't be forgotten here. As an example, look at Ricky Stuart and Parramatta. Stuart and the Eels have struggled to improve all season long whilst the Tigers and Potter have got improvement out of their young brigade. It is a great sign!

In 2014 Wests Tigers will go in a new direction minus Benji Marshall. They will rely even more so on the youth of the club. 18 year old Luke Brooks is expected to step into Benji's shoes. Fellow 18 year old Mitchell Moses won't be far behind either. In these two, the Tigers possess a potential key to success. I'm hoping Mick Potter will be there for the ride too. I've been impressed with Potter to this point. Sure, the NRL is a results driven business and so far Potter hasn't got results. But as I said earlier, there is method and reason behind the madness of 2013. A closer examination reveals Potter is doing good things at the Tigers.  Relieving him of his duties would be a case of shooting themselves in the foot for the Tigers. I just hope they don't go there. If Grant Mayer's comments are anything to go by, Tigers fans won't need to worry.